Termination

India
Grounds
Dismissals should be for ''reasonable cause'' – for example, redundancy, poor performance or continued ill health – especially in certain states, where the local S&E Act stipulates such a requirement. Otherwise, employees may be dismissed for misconduct (or ''for cause''). For workmen, the ID Act defines ''retrenchment'' as the termination by the employer of the service of a workman for any reason whatsoever, other than as a punishment inflicted by way of disciplinary action. However, "retrenchment" does not include voluntary retirement, reaching the stipulated superannuation age, non-renewal of a contract on expiry of its term, termination arising under such fixed-term contracts or termination of service on the grounds of an employee's continued ill health. The IR Code also specifies that termination of service of a worker as a result of completion of their fixed-term employment is not considered retrenchment.
An employer may for economic reasons reduce the number of its workmen, provided the process as stipulated in the ID Act is followed. The process to be followed will depend on whether the workmen to be retrenched have at least 1 year's (ie, 240 days) continuous employment and are:
- Employed in:
- Factories/mines/plantations with less than 100 employees or
- Other establishments
- Employed in factories, mines or plantations where the number of workmen employed in the last year is 100 or more – the ID Act has been amended in certain states to increase this threshold to 300 employees or more. The IR Code has increased this threshold to 300 employees across all states. Additionally, the IR Code also seeks to introduce a “worker re-skilling fund.” The IR Code provides that an employer shall be required to contribute an amount equal to 15 days’ wages or such amount as may be notified by the government for every retrenched worker. This amount will then be credited to the account of the retrenched worker in such manner as may be prescribed by the government.
For the ''non-workmen'' category of employees, their services may be terminated in the manner provided in their employment contracts and subject to complying with the provisions of the relevant S&E Act of the state.
Employees subject to termination laws
Where an employer plans to retrench a workman who has been in continuous service for at least 1 year (ie, 240 days) and who is employed in:
- Factories, mines or plantations with less than 100 employees or
- Other establishments, prescribed steps must be taken:
- Where the workman belongs to a particular category of workmen, in the absence of any agreement otherwise, the employer shall ordinarily retrench the workman who was the last person to be employed in that category. If the employer retrenches any other workman, it must record the reason for doing so (Last In First Out Rule).
- The workman must be given the requisite period of notice or payment in lieu of notice.
- Retrenchment compensation must be paid to the workman.
- Notice in the prescribed manner must be served upon the appropriate government authority.
Where an employer plans to retrench a workman who has been in continuous service for at least 1 year (ie, 240 days) in factories, mines or plantations where the number of workmen employed in the last year is 100 or more (300 in some states), the following steps should be taken:
- The Last In First Out Rule must be followed before retrenching the service of a workman
- The workman must be given the requisite period of notice or payment in lieu of notice
- Prior permission of the appropriate government authority must be obtained (see below) and
- Retrenchment compensation must be paid to the workman.
For "non-workmen," the steps the employer must take will be as stated in the employment contract and the provisions of the relevant S&E Act of the state.
Restricted or prohibited terminations
The level of protection granted to workmen in relation to the termination of their employment is higher where they are employed in factories, mines or plantations where the number of workmen employed in the last year is 100 or more (300 in some states). The ID Act prohibits termination of certain categories of workmen while a dispute is pending between them and their employer except with the approval of a designated authority. Under MBA, it is unlawful for an employer to discharge or dismiss a female employee while they are on statutory maternity leave. Similar protection is provided under ESI Act to employees who earn a monthly salary not exceeding INR 21,000 and who may be in receipt of certain statutory medical benefits provided under ESI Act.
Third-party approval for termination/termination documents
Where an employer plans to retrench a workman who has been in continuous service where the number of workmen employed in the last year is 100 or more (300 or more in some states), prior permission of the appropriate government authority must be obtained by the employer. The appropriate government authority, after making inquiries with the parties and considering the genuineness and adequacy of the relevant factors, will make an order either granting or refusing to grant permission. The order of the appropriate government authority is final and binding on all parties and remains in force for 1 year.
Mass layoff rules
The retrenchment procedure described above will equally apply to mass terminations.
Notice
Notice is required to be given prior to termination. The notice period may vary from state to state, but it is normally 1 month for ordinary dismissal, unless the employment contract provides for a longer notice period.
Where:
- An employer plans to retrench a workman who is employed in factories, mines or plantations with less than 100 employees or
- At other establishments, the employee is entitled to receive 1 month's notice or payment in lieu of such notice period.
Where an employer plans to retrench a workman who is employed in factories, mines or plantations where the number of workmen employed in the last year is 100 or more (300 in some states), the employee is entitled to receive 3 months' notice or payment in lieu of such notice period. In both cases, the notice of termination must be in writing and must indicate the reason for retrenchment.
Notification and permission from the appropriate government authority must also be obtained by the employer. See above.
Statutory right to pay in lieu of notice or garden leave
Employers may make a payment in lieu of notice. The right of workmen to receive retrenchment compensation is based on their length of service as of their last working day, irrespective of whether the termination is with immediate effect or after the employee has been asked to serve the notice period.
Garden leave is possible, though there is little case law to suggest how it will be enforced by the courts. It is preferable to include a specific garden leave in the contract of employment and company policy.
Severance
In case of a termination due to redundancy, employers are required to pay retrenchment compensation. Severance or retrenchment compensation equal to 15 days' average pay for every completed year of continuous service or part thereof in excess of 6 months must be paid to a workman on termination of employment. The provisions of the IR Code, pertaining to retrenchment are aligned with the provisions under the ID Act. However, for the purposes of retrenchment compensation, the same will be calculated at the rate of 15 days’ average pay or average pay of such number of days as may be notified by the appropriate government, for every completed year of continuous service or any part thereof in excess of 6 months. Additionally, as mentioned above, the IR Code also requires employer to contribute an amount equal to 15 days’ wages or such amount as may be notified by the government for every retrenched worker to a “worker re-skilling fund.”
In addition, the employer must pay certain termination benefits to employees who are dismissed, including leave encashment, gratuity payment (for employees, whether workmen or not, with 5 years or more of continuous service), payment in lieu of notice (if no notice is given), statutory bonus payment and any other amounts due under the employment contract. Employees who are being terminated on account of misconduct are not entitled to notice pay or retrenchment compensation.